I'll always prefer the first RTD run by a long shot, but I can't relate to those who claim Moffat is straight up bad. Even if his run is where I dropped the show for a long while. Moffat is the king of bottle episodes, and several of his are some of the very best of Who. Where he loses me is on the overarcing seasonal plotlines and general aesthetic vibes, which I feel RTD is much better at. Unfortunately, from what I hear from many concurrent fans, RTD's return has been severely hamstrung by Who becoming a Disney sponsored product so even those are lacking now.