Have you ever seen a theory that you felt is just wrong and you hate it

Before posting on the forum, be sure to read the Forum Rules.
Wednesday, August 20th, 2025, 11:24 PM3 months ago

[This thread will dive into some Deltarune spoilers. And mayhaps other media spoilers, depending on the replies I could get.]


Have you ever seen a theory that yall felt is just wrong? Like example, I see Homestuck class speculations, and my gut reaction is "WRONG!" But I dont argue about it because my reasoning is just as baseless. I'm not going to say my opinions on the classes due to said lack of evidence lolll. I will talk about something else here as a better example tho.


I will say that I don't like the theory that Carol from Deltarune is the knight. The sword the Knight summons LOOKS like a bat, before they swing it and transform it into a sword shape. Plus, I saw a REALLY compelling argument for Dess Knight. I saw a post on Tumblr that compared the Knight's movements to Figure Skating poses, and guess what's in Dess's room? ICE SKATES!


Anyways yeah. Anyone who doesn't like a popular fan theory from any fandom, feel free to explain why you don't like it. It can even be as simple as complaining about "it was all a dream" theories, which I also find stupid and wrong rip.

— matpat

matthew
Loading replies...
Topic: Have you ever seen a theory that you felt is just wrong and you hate it