How legally distinct would a Homestuck ripoff need to be to pass? (Theoretical question)

Before posting on the forum, be sure to read the Forum Rules.
Friday, August 8th, 2025, 11:59 PM27 days ago

I'm not actually going to do this, I'm just dying for an answer. And maybe someone else will take the bullet and make it free for the people.


I understand that there's not a lot to exploit here and that it'd be pretty easy to sue off the face of the earth in a lot of cases. But like, there has to be some way, right? It's not like the idea of a Homestuck story is copyrighted.


Doctor
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 0:02 AM27 days ago

Just write your own story? wtf are you talking about

Squiddo
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 0:04 AM27 days ago

No like the point is it's Homestuck. That's the point of the theoretical.


Doctor
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 0:07 AM27 days ago

Wdym it would be the same as any rip off right like what changes

Please foward all messages to your mothers house

AwesomeLoser
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 0:08 AM27 days ago

I am not a lawyer, but if I were hypothetically offering legal advice, having it on record that you were trying to be as close as possible to the original without breaking copyright is not going to look very good in a copyright case lmao


The image from that Tumblr post of a fox in the snow flinching from strong winds, captioned with "IT FUCKEN WIMDY", with the fox edited to have the god tier outfit of a Bard of Breath.


passeriInformal
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 0:14 AM27 days ago

I'm not doing it, of course, I'm just curious what the answer is. Because god forbid a guy be a Curious George. You can't even be a Curious George anymore


Doctor
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 0:20 AM27 days ago

i think if you changed the like gimmick of the trolls and the names of all the species and the name of the game and then also like switched up the humans and whatever you could probably get away with it, like instead of 4 humans playing Sburb with trolls you could do like 9 humans play a board game called Gnag, a game to destroy the cosmos, with a bunch of elves

“When I place my legs in a cage of spandex I dance like hell to release the madness!!

Zebruh
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 0:20 AM27 days ago

Instead of John Egbert his name is Pwn Noobert. Everything else remains exactly the same

That's it, I'm gonna do what I should have done a long time ago.

I'm going to beat him to death with this hammer.


READ BLOODSTUCK https://archiveofourown.org/works/66056185/chapters/170221711

Raffy
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 1:29 AM27 days ago

I'm imagining a mockbuster-style Homestuck ripoff you'd see at, like, CVS or something.

Check out my adventure Complete Idiocy on MSPFA! (https://mspfa.com/?s=64010&p=1)
Also check out my forum adventure YOU CAN'T SEE SQUAT! (https://www.fruityrumpus.com/forums/t/you-cant-see-squat)

PLEASE DO NOT USE DISCORD LINKS TO EMBED IMAGES INTO YOUR FORUM POSTS!!! THEY WILL STOP WORKING EVENTUALLY AND JUST LEAVE A GREY BOX!!!! USE FILEGARDEN!!!! IT'S FREE!!!!! (https://filegarden.com/)

Shelbybunny!
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 2:00 AM27 days ago

just call it ”Homosuck“, I doubt it’s trademarked. of course other details would have to be changed in order to be safe from copyright infringemen, but for branding purposes that’s probably as close as you could get.

This is some straight up delirious biznasty, Dawg!!

AwSnapz404
Saturday, August 9th, 2025, 5:44 AM27 days ago

Fuck everything else I want Pwn Noobert to be his canon name and have it so every instance of "John Egbert" is retroactively changed to Pwn Noobert

░█▀▄░█░█░█▀█░░█▀▀░▀█▀░█▀▀░█▀█░

░█░█░█░█░█▀▀█░▀▀█░░█░░█▀▀░█▀▀░

░▀▀░░▀▀▀░▀▀▀▀░▀▀▀░░▀░░▀▀▀░▀░░░

talentshredder
Topic: How legally distinct would a Homestuck ripoff need to be to pass? (Theoretical question)