possible inconsistency in the homestuck pilot

Before posting on the forum, be sure to read the Forum Rules.
Monday, September 29th, 2025, 6:11 PM16 days ago

in the pilot and the pilot trailer you see this shot of karkatand i dont think ive seen anyone point this out yet but i think there might be a slight timeline inconsistency in this frame


to explain: this is inside karkat's hive (oddly for some reason its the weird early version of his hive but that doesnt really matter) and oustide you can see alternia, from the green and pink moons


but we also see his lusus here in sprite form (as it was in the original panel this is based on which implies that this is after karkat entering the game , or possibly sometime during his entry process


i dont think they intentionally meant to set this during his entry process but im still taking that into consideration which means

1) they just forgot and its a slight timeline inconsistency

or 2) karkat randomly took a break to aurafarm while entering the game


this is a small nitpick and it doesnt really bother me that much but i just felt like pointing it out

Monday, September 29th, 2025, 7:31 PM16 days ago

The kernelsprite only turns into a full sprite after entering the Medium, so yes, this image is impossible.


I speculated in another thread that the reason we don't see this room ever again is because it's actually one of the ones Terezi adds on to Karkat's hive over the course of the game, which fits with it being clearly post-entry and being empty + light grey. But I myself never thought of that until that post, so it's not really a surprise that the animators thought of it as an alt version of Karkat's respiteblock, and thus drew him "hanging out" in it on Alternia. But yeah lol

Tuesday, September 30th, 2025, 1:20 AM16 days ago

t)(is bot)(ers me and 33l nefur be able to stawp t)(inking ameowt it w)(en i s33 it in the future

- Dear sweet Precious Fefeta FefetasplosianSploded


Dear Sweet Precious Fefeta
Tuesday, September 30th, 2025, 2:35 AM16 days ago

It is inconsistent, but I‘m completely certain that it is intentional. the color of his room combined with the sprite, it’s is absolutely a reference to the original image of karkat from the end of the intermission. I don’t like to speak in absolutes, but there’s just no way that’s not intentional.

This is some straight up delirious biznasty, Dawg!!

AwSnapz404
Tuesday, September 30th, 2025, 4:57 AM16 days ago

It being a redraw of that panel is absolutely not what's under question though? If you actually read the post???


In fact, in the original panel, the clouds outside Karkat's window are purple, which match the clouds in LOPAH. The clouds in the animation are dark red, like the ones above Karkat's hive on Alternia.

Tuesday, September 30th, 2025, 11:02 AM16 days ago

What I mean is, the question seems to be about the timeline, and I don’t think that was even a consideration. The white room and sprite are because of the panel from the end of the intermission, and alternia is is outside simply because they wanted to show Alternia. Meaning: i think it’s just meant to look cool, and has no bearing on the timeline.

This is some straight up delirious biznasty, Dawg!!

AwSnapz404
Tuesday, September 30th, 2025, 11:09 AM16 days ago

Them referencing that panel has nothing to do with the timeline error, though... that's in addition to the obvious reference to the panel. Imo, they interpreted that panel in a way that is technically impossible, due to an easy assumption to make.

Tuesday, September 30th, 2025, 11:13 AM16 days ago

Like if you want to show Alternia's moons to tease "this guy is on an alien world" why intentionally draw that one specific panel lol ... was the juxtaposition with Spades Slick that important? Maybe it was? But like if you're going to change the panel to focus on different things, why not change it further? Why include the cruxite? It would just be such a weird thing to do on purpose...

Tuesday, September 30th, 2025, 1:28 PM16 days ago

this!! and something that is making me SO MAD is Tavros not being in his wheelchair and people are like "w-well its probably a spoiler thing..!!" THEN WHY DOES VRISKA HAVE HER ROBO ARM???? AUUGGHHHHHH PMO PMO PMO guh

rails b4 pails!!

:O3

meowmewo


MEOW
Tuesday, September 30th, 2025, 7:36 PM15 days ago

@meowzers I NEVER NOTICED THAT ACTuALLY. THATS QuITE LAME.

Sincerely, rupaul superfans

undyingUmbrage
Wednesday, October 1st, 2025, 1:08 AM15 days ago

vriska steals the spotlight once more and of the same guy she always does


swag


Wednesday, October 1st, 2025, 1:12 PM15 days ago

@davestrider

man im a D1 Vriska HATER!!!

rails b4 pails!!

:O3

meowmewo


MEOW
Topic: possible inconsistency in the homestuck pilot