@stagelights

I'm not going to say that I don't understand where you're coming from, because I also was a big fan of transfem roxy, but I do think you're bringing baggage into this thread where it doesn't exist. no one here is saying that transfem roxy is an illegal thing to headcanon. people here are complaining about the fact that people as a whole have just completely ignored everything to do with transmasc roxy.

I legitimately, 100% do not believe that anyone here thinks it is a Bad Thing to hc roxy as transfem (except maybe the atlas shrugged guy idk what's up with him). you talk about transfem erasure, and that's a fair perspective to have, but what's being talked about is trans erasure wholesale. the fandom at large just completely rejects the idea of roxy being anything but a cis woman, and that's a problem.