i saw a response on cami's thread https://www.fruityrumpus.com/forums/t/my-full-conversation-with-gio-1?page=2 that i rly agree with and wanted to push
RE: "This conversation is bizzare to me because it's predicated on the idea Gio has some sort of basic human right to distribute copyrighted material (the asset pack) without a license for money (Gio has a Patreon). (via user bluebootyranger)"
LITERALLY THIS. WHY DO PEOPLE ON THIS FORUM KEEP SAYING IT WAS "SHITTY" OF ANDREW HUSSIE TO USE LEGAL THREATS AGAINST GIO WHEN GIO CLAIMS ANY FORM OF AUTHORITY OVER 8000 PAGES OF WORK ANDREW HUSSIE MADE WITH THEIR OWN HANDS (bambosh made the original tech for the unofficial collection btw). UNDER WHAT CIRCUMSTANCE IS ANDREW HUSSIE'S, OR *ANYBODY'S* WORK SOME KIND OF PUBLIC RESOURCE THAT JUST ANY OLD SHMUCK WHO WALKS IN CAN CLAIM OR PROFIT OFF OF??? LIKE DUDE. EVEN IF ANDREW HUSSIE'S ONLY REASON FOR DMCAING GIO IS BECAUSE HE SIMPLY DOES NOT LIKE HIM, THATS... FINE????????!!!!!!!!!!!!?!!!!!!! ITS A "GET THE FUCK OUT OF MY HOUSE" SITUATION, AND FRANKLY INSTEAD OF THREATENING HIM AT ALL HE SHOULD HAVE SKIPPED STRAIGHT TO FUCKING COURT. I CANT STAND PEOPLE ACTING LIKE CREATORS SHOULD ALWAYS BE NICE TO THEIR FANS JUST BECAUSE THEY OWE US? THEY DONT OWE US SHIT, THEY MADE THE FUCKING WORK.
PEOPLE ARE FORGETTING THAT CREATORS, ESPECIALLY ONLINE CREATORS, DONT REALLY HAVE MUCH RECOURSE AGAINST BAD ACTORS WHO TAKE CREDIT FOR THEIR WORK BESIDE LEGAL. LIKE WTF ARE YOU EXPECTING, *******************A COOKIE??????????????????????????????????******************************
> READ GODHEAD at SPICYYETI.COM
It's like Homestuck but during Antebellum slavery.
In itself, no, but Gio was a proud member of harassment campaigns (at the same time, tied together) with more than one team member - I was there and saw all this shit go down on twitter and the reddit. multiple team members after leaving requested to not be brought up or named because they've had enough bullshit and people (like gio) pointing mobs at them looking for "answers" that ultimately had nothing to do with them. but people wanted someone that they could touch to harass, which is the same reason that Gio ultimately tells people to stop supporting HSBC/FRAF (even though their money is entirely separate from Hussie), because those are the people he can reach and make their lives harder. It's the same shit all over again, except this time Gio wrote his blog post in the middle of a hissy fit after screwing himself out of a deal that would actually give him distinction and relevancy beyond his own failing blog & patreon, so now the mask is off.
do you have any evidence (screenshots or links will suffice) linking Gio to twitter harassment campaigns? I’ve seen people make this claim several times and no one has backed it up.
tara and raven superfan
If you and your friends who were being harassed and made to feel unsafe weren't taking screenshots and documenting everything then that's on you actually.
Especially considering part of all that shit was discords getting deleted and accounts being wiped.
i feel as though I may have a completely separate perspective from a majority of people due to some of the social circles I was in, where people such as Aysha, Kate, Lalo, Sarah Zedig (who I must say did also do youtube videos and in a kinder world the sarah z homestuck video would be a collab with sarah zedig instead because itd be funnyyyyy), etc etc
and so in my eyes the harassment that the people who were working on things when the videos came out, not those old studios that closed or the breakdown of communications with TOG, but the people currently working on things who were inescapably harassed about it and had their reputations sullied after the video dropped is the bigger issue for me than what the video said about hussie in specific
and i think taking longer (and not yaknow trying to hit a 4/13 release for teh lulz) and doing more thorough research and talking to the people involved from the jump could have gone a long way in preventing a lot of frustrations, misunderstandings, anger, and so on
if you have no evidence linking Gio to any harassment claims, that seems like hearsay or a malicious lie to me.
tara and raven superfan
it's only hearsay or a malicious lie if hussie said it, if gio said it it is the truth.
see, there you go! i can't search for any of the ex-members' tweets because they're all deleted accounts after they were harassed off the platform, and i'm DEFINITELY not showing you their new accounts elsewhere.
I guess I can give you a recent quote that comes up when i search your name on twitter, though! feel free to verify yourself:
"i did not step down from vast error because andrew hussie forced me to or didn't like me. we literally did an interview together. i stepped down from vast error because i worked on it for nearly 14 years and because i'm tired of getting embroiled in stupid shit like this.
i can say with a measure of certainty that every article gio has ever written about homestuck that the information is tainted with malintent."
- Austin Vast Error
With that, I'm inviting all further conversation to once again return to the premise of this thread, Gio, you're free to make your own thread begging for more screenshots.
DOES, or DOES NOT, Hussie have the right to distance themself AND HIS COMIC/BRAND from people who cause them trouble?
Also for what it's worth, TOG did work on Act 7, but WP provides evidence that this was separate from the kickstarter agreement and had an understanding with TOG that it would not affect Hiveswap or the funds for it. Hussie tried to meet with TOG for nearly a year to assess their progress, and they avoided her. If you want to check all this shit again, I think that one hiveswap tumblr has the link to the post. But like it patently did not confirm what the Sarah Z video or Gio blog post claimed? The one thing I'll give there is the sudden dismissal of WP NYC, which was bad and a sign of Hussie mismanaging the project. However, mismanaging a project is not like, a crime? That happens with plenty of videogame kickstarters. It sucks, but it's not Hussie being an evil abuser. Also, the WP response once again alleges that the information comes from a bad source, a source that was dangerous to people, and that spreading this information is damaging. Whether you believe that or not, that is a very valid reason from Hussie's own perspective to not want those articles up.
There is basically nothing to show that Hussie like, what, deliberately lost the funds? Abused people? The worst you can really accuse him of is being a bad businessman.
as someone who was around when that drama was going on, my impression is that the snake solutions team you reference was harassed by an unguided mob of twitter and 4chan users who did not care for their personalities or direction that homestuck 2 was going on (yiffany being introduced in particular made a lot of people angry), and Gio had little do with it. nor does it make much sense that Gio would be the reason for this harassment when most of those people had never worked on Hiveswap during the time period gios article focuses on.
tara and raven superfan
At a certain point were just talking around the troll and I get that, but the fascination with 'evidence' kind of gets me because like, I'm no big city lawyer, but to my understanding in most jurisdictions repeated corroborated witness testimony from several relevant and present individuals, counts as evidence
testimony generally needs to describe something concrete. what inciting words did Gio say that led to the harassment occurring? can what he said be corroborated with other witnesses? and so on. the claims I’ve seen for this have been uselessly vague.
tara and raven superfan
Do you not think gio's constant criticisms of the team in his trademark extremely inflammatory manner, calling them abusive and implying horrible things about them, contributed to that at all? So you not think his constant hounding of the authors and attempts to infiltrate private discord servers to dig up information on them, along with the very pushy and uncomfy way he's been seen to talk to fem people, had anything to do with people's discomfort and unease?
Also, before a mod jumps in again, for all the folks defending, recall that the original director of HS2 does not want to be named in this even for defense. That's all.
Yeah I'm sure 4chan users don't care for the personality of a trans woman and non-binary palestinian.
But I guess das just your impression. You fucking wanker
-- The Butch
You know this kind of ties back to what I was saying about how Hussie's lawyers backing away from this situation isn't indicative of it being true or whatever, because there's a bunch of reasons for why libel cases fail. Most people are very aware of the harassment campaign that happened, but the internet is unfortunately not actually "forever" and things can get lost pretty easily. The objective reality of what happened and what most people in the Homestuck fandom remember VS the physical or digital proof of these things happening contradict each other because we don't actually have an accurate account OF what happened. No one was archiving this, and the people involved wanted to just step back after it all went down.
And even if people were, it would be super easy to just dismiss it all by going "None of this matters + it's just personal attacks, people are allowed to call each other mean names on the internet," which is also true.
I will also point out that it is a bit ironic to be in the thread demanding people give you proof of what happened, when the person you're defending has cropped out discord chat logs as their only "proof" of this situation.
most of gios criticisms in the disputes article are of Andrew hussie, not the homestuck 2 team. the main occasion when the homestuck 2 team is referenced at all is when they made public comments on social media disparaging Gio and Sarah z. he also mentions joining a discord server they operated at one point where the disparaging comments were made. he leaves snarky comments about this and complains that this is bad behavior. you can say Gio is equally guilty of inflammatory rhetoric, but at no point does he ask anyone to harass or attack the homestuck 2 trans social media.
tara and raven superfan
"the homestuck 2 trans social media"
-- The Butch